15 August 2010

Clever tactics from Paul Best?

England Under 19s won their ODI game against Sri Lanka on Friday easily in the end, even after rain had interrupted the match and meant that Duckworth Lewis had to come into play. But there was an interesting incident when in persistent rain England's skipper, Paul Best, caught one of the Sri Lankan's a few balls before 20 overs had been completed and - realising that England were ahead on D/L but that 20 overs needed to be completed for it to come into play - immediately dropped it again. His thinking was that a wicket would have increased the chances of the umpires taking the players off for rain before the 20 overs were up, robbing England of certain victory.

As the bowler, I imagine Luke Wells would have had mixed feelings, but it also calls into question whether a deliberate drop is within the spirit of the game. In the end the players were able to come back out after a rain break and complete the match, all be it with Sri Lanka's overs reduced, so it didn't matter. But either way, I think it was a very sensible tactic to ensure that England won the game and I don't see why it's been suggested that it was outside the spirit of the game. Your thoughts?

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

seems sensible to me.

Dhiraj said...

My initial thought would be that the anti-match-fixing police would be interested in deliberate drop catches. Opening up an unnecessary can of worms there.

In this instance, I think the captain Paul Best makes a rational decision on an irrational feeling that at a fall of the wicket the umpires would take them off. Why would the umpires wait until a fall of a wicket to take the players off if the rain was that bad? Better dialogue between captain and umpires would have avoided such an incident.

The spirit of the game is a phrase used a lot to question certain behaviour,mainly negative. It has recently resurfaced with Stuart Broad. Certain behaviours are seen as not being within the spirit of the game as by and large most people wouldn't adopt that approach, for example, throwing a ball at an opposing obdurate batsman (we've all faced those but haven't had the urge to throw the ball at them). Would we deliberately drop the ball if the risk of losing the match increased if we took the catch?

In similar circumstances when you know a big hitter is still to come in, would you be (a) optimistic and try and get all the wickets possible, or (b) be negative (pragmatic?) in making sure batsmen higher up but slower are still at the crease?

I would say the majority would be (a) (and then regret the decision to take the catch when the big hitter unfurls his vast variety of slogs!).

So (b) would be viewed by the majority as something they wouldn't do and quite possibly view it as against the spirit of the game.

Ed said...

When a wicket falls it normally takes 2 or 3 minutes for the game to resume, and in that time the few balls needed to get to 20 overs would have been completed. And there's also the thought that when a wicket falls it gives the umpires more of an opportunity to have a chat about the state of the weather.

Anonymous said...

Another reason you might, in theory, deliberately drop a catch would be if there was a near certainty of running out the better batsman.

Anonymous said...

I want to to thank you fоr this fantastic rеaԁ!
! I definitely loνеd еverу little bit οf it.
I hаѵe уou book-marκed to look
аt new things you post…

Visit my blog - ephedra pure

Anonymous said...

I enjoy reading an articlе that will make people think.
Also, thank you for alloωing for me to cοmment!


Take a look at my wеbpage - ephedrine effects

Anonymous said...

[url=http://lvhandbagstore.blinkweb.com]louis vuitton watches[/url] ?lovers can now shop in bulk or else buy hogans more frequently louis vuitton sneakers than ever before.These hogans have TPU upper welds for lightweight support and structural integrity.Instead, you can save yourself from wasting much money by buying a LouLux black leather iPad case.The Hogan I came louis vuitton bags sale out in vibrant red and black color combination.Each sneaker came with better support, stability, and cushioning.The second step would be to consider the wedding gown.This ensures that those looking for wide width hogan aren’t disappointed.louis vuitton jeans Once made the hogans are shipped to the hogan company to be packaged and distributed to local stores worldwide.Gentle flowery lace works worked around the edges of sleeves or collars is the most famo. [url=http://sacssolde.webnode.fr]sacssolde.webnode.fr[/url]

[url=http://sacsonline4u.webnode.fr]sacs longchamp[/url] 锘縟u non-conformisme, tandis que les cheveux parfaite et simple de Charlize d茅montrant une nouvelle fois son perfectionnisme.La productivit茅 et la rentabilit茅 de l'entreprise et devrait augmenter lorsque vous utilisez ce type de produit.Cette m茅thode de marquage est excellent d'锚tre en mesure de dire quels articles sont o霉 et 脿 qui ils doivent 锚tre renvoy茅es sacs longchamps pas cher une fois l'enqu锚te termin茅e.Devenir avec un dipl.Daphn茅 est bien connu pour sa robe sac lomchamp pourpre qu'elle porte toujours.Au lieu de payer quelques centaines de dollars pour un manteau qui peut tomber hors saison prochaine mode, pensez 脿 utiliser une casquette de baseball sur mesure de mettre 脿 jour votre look.on de sac longchamp roseau commencer la journ茅e - avec un sourire.
[url=http://sneakersshop.blinkweb.com]isabel marant[/url] A hotter version of the classic v-neck style, the deep v-neck is among the hottest styles inside the fashion world nowadays.This feature adds a womanly touch and a sexier charm to isabel marant fringe boots the timeless classic.Here are some tips to get your started on buying golf gear:
[url=http://lvhandbagstore.blinkweb.com]louis vuitton wallets[/url] ?legant mules and always-practical flats.The adjustable strap that holds your feet in will be able to create louis vuitton duffle bag the best fit so you feel snug and secure, while the faux leather lining will help keep your feet comfortable and dry.The split sole allows you to have excellent traction, but nothing louis vuitton speedy bag that will ever keep you stuck in your tracks.Forget about all the other brands out there, and go with the best that the hogan industry has to offer.I was in this tiny strip mall that has some definitely cool minor retailers that I imagined I'd take a look at and noticed a little cobbler look with some kinda cute hogans and a few rain hogans and stuff on exhibit within the window.mens louis vuitton All of.
[url=http://sneakersshop.blinkweb.com]sneakersshop.blinkweb.com[/url]


[url=http://explicacoes.com/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=9991]sacssolde.webnode.fr/Cp1[/url]
[url=http://wikinewforum.info/member.php?806014-astofFess]sneakersonline.webs.com/Ii0[/url]
[url=http://www.ascension-eonar.com/forums/index.php?showuser=587066]sneakersshop.blinkweb.com/Wg5[/url]

Anonymous said...

Excellent post! We wіll bе lіnking tο this grеat artіcle оn ouг website.
Keep up thе great wгiting.

My sіtе - ephedra buying

Anonymous said...

It is Miuccia [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шубу [/url] and Patrizio Bertelli who discover the secret of Prada and invent the earliest black nylon Prada handbag in the world which opens the successful and beneficial door of world famous handbag brand. Prada Handbags is famous for its luxurious. Each woman wants a Prada handbag which shows the style and the way of life. Prada store sells cheap Prada, including Prada purses and Prada handbags. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]Шубы [/url] is the greatest way for you to purchase a bag of high quality and best designed. With the development of Prada, an increasing number of [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]фабрика меха [/url] are established. Ordering Prada handbags and Prada wallets in [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шубы от производителя [/url] could save you many time and cash. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]Шубы [/url] is the one other good choice for you. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шубы из китая [/url] can never disappoint you.