Disagreeing with Atherton again...

I'm a big Atherton fan but I find myself disagreeing with him again, this time over whether Vaughan should have come straight back in. If he'd been out with a recurrence of his knee injury, or if we had someone who could do as good a job as captain, then I might be swayed Michael, but not when he's been fit for a while now barring a broken finger, hardly the most dangerous of injuries unless repeated several times on the same digit. And let's face it - we hardly have anyone knocking on the door in terms of captaincy credentials - even if Vaughan bags a pair he'll effectively average 40 with his captaincy decisions versus Strauss, and plenty more than that compared with Flintoff.